How to Properly Break In Your Baseball Glove: Tips for Every Level of Play

A well-broken-in baseball glove feels like an extension of your hand. Whether you're a budding player or a seasoned pro, properly breaking in your glove can make a world of difference on the field. Here’s a step-by-step guide to ensure your glove performs at its best, tailored to the quality of leather your glove is made from: Prospect (cowhide), Elite (steerhide), or Pro (Japanese kip leather).

Why Break In Your Glove?

Breaking in a baseball glove softens the leather and molds it to fit your hand and playing style. This enhances grip, comfort, and overall performance. Each type of leather has its unique characteristics, and breaking in the glove properly ensures longevity and peak performance.


Step-by-Step Glove Break-In Process

Step 1: Understand Your Glove’s Leather

  1. Prospect Gloves (100% Cowhide Leather):

    • Cowhide is soft, making these gloves easier to break in. Perfect for younger players or casual athletes.
  2. Elite Gloves (100% Steerhide Leather):

    • Steerhide is tougher and more durable than cowhide. Breaking in will take more time and effort but provides lasting performance.
  3. Pro Gloves (100% Japanese Kip Leather):

    • Japanese kip leather is lightweight, durable, and molds beautifully to your hand. It's a favorite for professional players but requires a patient, precise break-in process.

Step 2: Gather Your Tools

  • A baseball or softball
  • A glove mallet (or a similar tool)
  • A clean rag
  • Glove conditioner (ensure it’s safe for your leather type)
  • Rubber bands or bungee cords

Step 3: Conditioning Your Glove

Apply a small amount of glove conditioner to the leather. This softens and protects it. Use a clean rag to rub the conditioner evenly across the entire glove.

  • Prospect Gloves: Use sparingly, as cowhide absorbs conditioner quickly.
  • Elite Gloves: Apply a bit more to penetrate the tougher steerhide.
  • Pro Gloves: Focus on even application, as kip leather is delicate and benefits from balanced conditioning.

Step 4: Shape the Glove

  1. Place a baseball or softball in the pocket.
  2. Close the glove around the ball as you would in a game.
  3. Secure the glove with rubber bands or bungee cords to maintain the shape.

Step 5: Work the Leather

  • Use a glove mallet to pound the pocket and break in the hinge points (where the glove folds).
  • For Prospect Gloves, this step is quick and effective.
  • For Elite Gloves, focus on repeatedly hitting the same areas to soften the durable leather.
  • For Pro Gloves, use even, controlled strikes to mold the high-quality leather.

Step 6: Play Catch

There’s no substitute for real-world use. Spend time catching balls with your glove to naturally break it in. Start with lighter throws and gradually increase intensity.


Step 7: Repeat as Needed

Breaking in your glove is a process, not a one-time event. Repeat these steps until your glove feels like a perfect fit.


Tips for Long-Term Care

  • Store your glove in a cool, dry place to prevent cracking or damage.
  • Regularly clean and condition your glove to maintain softness and durability.
  • Avoid over-conditioning, as this can weaken the leather over time.

Choosing the Right Glove for Your Needs

Whether you’re just starting out or aiming for the big leagues, our gloves are designed to grow with you:

  • Prospect Gloves: Affordable, easy to break in, and ideal for beginners.
  • Elite Gloves: A step up for competitive players, offering unmatched durability.
  • Pro Gloves: Premium performance for serious athletes, crafted from the finest Japanese kip leather.

Final Thoughts
Breaking in your glove is an essential step to elevate your game. With patience and care, you’ll create a trusted companion on the field, no matter your skill level.

Ready to find your perfect glove? Explore our collection today and start breaking in the glove that’s right for you!

Back to blog